Most common supplements recommended by providers or requested by patients
With all the advertising around vitamins, supplements and herbs, it is hard to know which ones are worth your money. Because supplements are not regulated by the FDA the way prescription medications are, it is not always possible to know whether a bottle contains the ingredient, or the amount, it claims to.
One thing worth looking for is third-party testing by an outside lab such as USP. And talk to your provider about anything you are taking or considering, because supplements may or may not be indicated for your health conditions and some interact with prescriptions. A few can cause harm if you do not actually have a deficiency, or if your levels are already high.
Here is what we tell patients about the seven we get asked about most.
1. Magnesium
Magnesium is involved in a huge number of cellular processes. It supports muscle function, sleep quality, gastrointestinal motility, heart health and bone strength. Food sources include nuts, seeds, whole grains, beans, leafy vegetables and dairy.
The part that confuses people is that magnesium supplements come in several forms, and they are not interchangeable.
If you have tried magnesium and given up because it upset your stomach, you may simply have had the wrong form. Magnesium glycinate causes fewer gastrointestinal side effects than citrate or oxide, which is why it is usually where we start for someone who wants magnesium for sleep or cramps rather than for constipation.
Magnesium L-threonate is the one you see marketed for memory and focus. It does cross into the brain more easily, though the human evidence for cognitive benefit is still early.
Magnesium can also help with headaches / migraines if taken in the right dosages - connect with your primary care provider to get more information if you suffer from headaches / migraines.
2. Vitamin D
Vitamin D helps your body absorb calcium, which matters for building and keeping bone density. It also supports nerve signaling, reduces inflammation and helps the immune system.
Few foods contain vitamin D naturally, though many in the US are fortified with it, and your body makes its own when your skin is exposed to sunlight. Deficiency is common here, mostly from limited sun exposure and diet.
Many people do well on vitamin D3 at 1,000 IU daily, but more is not better and too much causes its own problems. This is one where testing your level first is genuinely worth it. We go into more depth in our post on bone health and osteoporosis prevention.
3. Fish Oil
Fish oil contains the omega-3 fatty acids EPA and DHA. Diets high in omega-3s are associated with lower heart disease risk, but trials of fish oil supplements have largely not reproduced that cardiovascular benefit.
What supplements do appear to help with is lowering blood pressure and triglycerides, the fats circulating in your blood. There is also evidence they may slow cognitive decline.
Food sources are salmon, tuna, sardines, mackerel, shellfish, flaxseed, walnuts and pumpkin seeds. If your triglycerides are high, there are also prescription omega-3 formulations that behave differently from the bottle on the shelf, which is a conversation worth having with your provider.
4. Vitamin B12
B12 supports red blood cell formation, which is why deficiency causes anemia and fatigue. It is also needed for nerve function and DNA production, and low levels are linked with cognitive problems.
Most people get enough from food. Supplementation genuinely matters for vegans and vegetarians, for anyone who cannot absorb B12 well, including people with celiac disease, Crohn's or a history of gastrointestinal surgery, and for older adults, where deficiency is common.
One correction worth making, because you will see it repeated everywhere. B12 does lower homocysteine, and high homocysteine is associated with cardiovascular disease. But the National Institutes of Health is clear that supplementing with B12, alone or with other B vitamins, does not prevent heart attacks or reduce death rates. Take B12 because you are deficient or at risk of becoming deficient, not for your heart.
5. Collagen
Collagen is a protein that supports skin, muscle, bone and connective tissue. The studies are mixed, though one meta-analysis of 26 studies did find improvement in skin hydration and elasticity with hydrolyzed collagen.
You cannot absorb collagen whole. Your body builds its own from the individual amino acids it gets from food and supplements. Smoking, sun damage, aging and alcohol all reduce how much collagen you make.
Eating well, along the lines of a Mediterranean diet, does more for your skin than any capsule.
6. Creatine
Creatine is one of the most studied supplements there is, both for safety and for effectiveness. It boosts energy production inside muscle cells, which improves performance in high-intensity activity and supports muscle growth. There is also some evidence it supports brain function and may protect nerve cells.
The usual dose of creatine monohydrate is 3 to 5 grams a day. Side effects can include gastrointestinal upset and some water weight gain. Talk to your provider first if you have diabetes, kidney disease or liver disease.
Creatine is not just for young athletes. Preserving muscle matters more with age, not less, which is why it comes up often in conversations about menopause and bone health and about staying strong on a GLP-1 medication.
7. Iron
Iron deficiency causes anemia and fatigue, and women with heavy periods are among the most commonly affected.
Two things matter here. First, if you are iron deficient, it is important to find out why, because deficiency can be the first sign of something that needs attention. Second, iron supplements are important when you have a confirmed deficiency, and generally a bad idea when you do not. Extra iron you do not need causes gastrointestinal side effects and, in some people, builds up to harmful levels.
This is the clearest example on the list of why you test before you supplement.
Test First, Then Decide
Most of this comes down to the same thing. A supplement that corrects a real deficiency can make a genuine difference. The same supplement taken without one is, at best, expensive, and occasionally harmful.
Vitamin D, B12, iron and ferritin are all simple blood tests. At Smartypants Medicine, labs are run at cost rather than marked up, and appointments run 30 to 60 minutes, which is enough time to go through everything in your cabinet properly rather than in the last ninety seconds of a visit.
Bring the bottles. We would rather see what you are actually taking.
Call us at 540-692-6132 or see what a membership includes. We are at 1824 Plaza Dr. in Winchester and see patients across Frederick, Shenandoah, and Clarke Counties.
This article is general education, not medical advice. Talk with your provider before starting or stopping any supplement, especially if you take prescription medication.
About the author
Kelly Botta, PA-C is the President of Smartypants Medicine in Winchester, VA, and brings 15 years of internal medicine experience to the exam room.
.png)


